Koinly doesnt work when Staking

[Johannes_Riediger]

I Demand answers now from the Team after we had multiplte posts on this.

I bought 10802 CRO on Jan 23rd, and send them to the pool because i staked them for the VISA Card. This will make them a 10year Holding Period before they become tax free in Germany.

After that i bought another 20000 Cro which i sold just now and Koinly uses Fifo and when checking the Cost Analysis it sold the 10802 CRO which still sit in the Pool. It doenst even consider that and just sold them Fifo. So now i have a false tax statement because the wrong coins were sold at a different cost basis and it doesnt tag the Coins as 10Years because they were staked which leads to another wrong calculation later. So Koinly isnt working for German Tax Law?

IS there anything you have to say about that or are you just going to not answer german tax law questions about your Software and its missing points again like the last Threads?

[Jon_Mardell]

i dont think “demanding” anything is going to get you very far but you can change the cost basis in settings to not use FIFO and use another method ACB / LIFO / HIFO

[Johannes_Riediger]

I paid for a product that doesnt deliver what it promises so demanding is the way actually! But they never answer anyway.

And it doesnt help me to change it from Fifo to ACB oder LIFO because that is not accepted in Germany and doesnt solve the Problem!

[Jon_Mardell]

i have tried many solutions and koinly is the best by far for what i need, not perfect yet but what it is missing for me is being worked on so soon it will be the perfect product. if you are not happy look at other options which maybe more suitable.

[Johannes_Riediger]

There is never an answer here from the team behind Koinly. Sad Stuff, promising features, taking money and dont care about not working Features. Thanks !