This could be for a number of reason, my guess is that its to do with the cost-basis method, which does not necessarily mean that the calculation is incorrect.
If you expand the “Sell” transaction, and navigate to the Cost-Analysis tab, you will see how Koinly worked out that profit figure.
Though you purchased ETH on Aug 7th, the “Sell” on Aug 17th is not using that as it’s cost-basis.
Let me know how you get on and do get back to me if anything doesn’t look right.